I was looking at the description of espace étalé (see Wikipedia’s article on sheaves) in J.S. Milne’s lecture notes on etale cohomology where I saw this scary sentence: “It is possible to avoid using these spaces — in fact Grothendieck has banished them from mathematics — but they are quite useful, for example, for defining the inverse image of a sheaf”. Well, I hope for Milne’s sake that Grothendieck never finds out.
Author Archives: Walt
Iskra on Really Modern Algebra
In a glimpse of humanity’s future, which will be a grim dystopia for me and a paradise for everyone else, John Iskra is writing an undergraduate algebra text written purely from a categorical point of view, called Really Modern Algebra. It’s far from complete, but at 70 pages you can see where he’s going. He’s currently teaching a course out of the book, and also provides his slides from lectures.
Natural Operations in Differential Geometry
If anyone is interested in some more synthetic differential geometric goodness, the point of view of the book Natural Operations in Differential Geometry by Ivan Kolar, Jan Slovak and Peter W. Michor, while couched in a more traditional language, is quite close to that of synthetic differential geometry. In Natural Operations, the authors are trying to classify functors on the category of differentiable manifolds (this is what they call a natural operation). Synthetic differential geometry tries to define a larger category so that those functors become representable.
Cosmic Variance on Boltzmann
Sean at Cosmic Variance has a very interesting post on Boltzmann and entropy. Given that entropy is generally increasing, why was the universe ever in a low-entropy state? One idea proposed by Boltzmann himself is that we are living in a small low-entropy fluctuation in a much larger universe. (According to statistical mechanics, entropy can decrease, but is just very unlikely to do so.) If we take Boltzmann’s idea seriously, then we would expect to be living in the most likely fluctuation compatible with our existence, which does not seem to be the case. Sean has much more on this.
Bacon on Quantum Computing
This post by Dave Bacon on his weblog, makes quantum computing sound like a modest extension of classical computing, which works by speeding up computation of Fourier transforms on Z/2Z: quantum computers can be built up out of two different gates, the Toffoli gate (which is universal for classical computation), and the Hadamard gate, which implements the Fourier transform on Z/2Z. The full discrete Fourier transform can be built out of this special case.
Dave links to a short proof of the universality of this family of gates by Dorit Aharonov.
Sard’s Theorem
I was curious if the statement of Sard’s Theorem was the best possible. Curiously, the best answer I could find was on Everything 2, which describes an improvement in terms of Hausdorff measure zero sets.
Poincare Conjecture Settled?
I see via Peter Woit that a new preprint by John Morgan and Gang Tian has appeared on arXiv, Ricci Flow and the Poincare Conjecture, which claims to offer a complete proof of the Poincare Conjecture, based on Perelman’s sketch. Huai-Dong Cao and Xi-Ping Zhu’s proof of the complete Geometrization Conjecture has been published in the Asian Journal of Mathematics, and is now available online as A Complete Proof of the Poincaré and Geometrization Conjectures – Application of the Hamilton-Perelman theory of the Ricci flow.
Huneke and Taylor on Local Cohomology
I found some nice lecture notes on local cohomology (in commutative algebra) by Craig Huneke, with an appendix by Amelia Taylor.
Kock on synthetic differential geometry
Synthetic differential geometry is an attempt to reformulate differential geometry to allow infinitesimals. Unlike nonstandard analysis, these infinitesimals are nilpotent, and the operation of taking the derivative of a function at a point becomes just evaluating the function at a nilpotent infinitesimal near that point. The idea was used heuristically in the nineteenth century, but the inspiration from the modern reformulation comes from commutative algebra, where the idea is unproblematic.
Anders Kock has made his book on the subject, Synthetic Differential Geometry, available for download on his website. The book is being reprinted, so he asks readers not to circulate printed copies.
Invariant Subspace Problem
I was recently reminded of the invariant subspace problem in Hilbert spaces: the question of whether every bounded operator on a Hilbert space has a closed invariant subspace. Of famous open problems in mathematics, this one is perhaps the most surprising. It sounds like it should be exercise 7 of chapter 2 of a book on Hilbert spaces; yet the answer is still unknown. (I have no idea what the answer should be; I’m just surprised that it’s so hard to figure out one way or the other. What makes it particularly surprising is the answer is known for Banach spaces.)
B. F. Yadav has a survey article on the subject The Invariant Subspace Problem. It appears in Nieuw Archief voor Wiskunde, a publication of the Royal Dutch Mathematical Society, which prints the occasional article in English.