Paul Cohen, 1934-2007

Alexandre Borovik is reporting that Paul Cohen has died. Cohen of course proved that the continuum hypothesis is independent of the axioms of set theory, and that the axiom of choice was independent of the other axioms.

Gödel had already established that both the continuum hypothesis and axiom of choice were consistent, in the sense if you could derive a contradiction by adding them as axioms then you could derive a contradiction in set theory without them. Gödel accomplished this by defining a certain minimal model of set theory, the constructible universe, and showing that in this model both axioms hold. Cohen then completed the proof of independence by showing that you can construct a model of set theory in which both axioms are false. To do so, he had to invent a new technique: forcing.

His Wikipedia biography has the oddest snippet:

His twin sons Steven and Eric played the Dancing Twins on the TV show Ally McBeal.

Is that really true?

Latest Paper on ArXiv

I have seen references here and there to a new paper on ArXiv, The Riemann Hypothesis, by Tribikram Pati, that claims to derive a contradiction from the Riemann Hypothesis. I caution anyone who’s seen it to not to get too excited. The gap between thinking you have a proof and actually having a proof can be large, and it’s particularly large for a famous problem. Since ArXiv if for preprints and not-necessarily-polished work, people can and do upload papers that they have to retract later.

The argument in the paper is fairly elementary, using only basic real and complex analysis, so if anyone is interested in seeing if they can find a flaw in the argument I’d recommend giving it a try.

Why Navier-Stokes is Hard

Terence Tao has a thoughtful post that explains why proving existence results for Navier-Stokes equations is so hard.

phentermine buy phentermine phentermine online buy cheap phentermine buy phentermine cod buy phentermine online cheap phentermine cheap phentermine online cheapest phentermine discount phentermine does phentermine work effects of phentermine generic phentermine herbal phentermine online pharmacy phentermine order phentermine order phentermine online phentermine 30mg phentermine 37 phentermine 37.5 90 phentermine 90 phentermine adipex phentermine blue phentermine cod phentermine com phentermine diet phentermine diet pill phentermine diet pills phentermine drug phentermine effects phentermine florida phentermine free phentermine free shipping phentermine hcl phentermine information phentermine mastercard phentermine no prescription phentermine on line phentermine online prescription phentermine overnight phentermine pharmacy phentermine pill phentermine pills phentermine price phentermine purchase phentermine rx phentermine sale phentermine side effects phentermine tablets phentermine weight loss phentermine without a prescription phentermine without prescription phentermine yellow prescription phentermine side effects of phentermine what is phentermine www phentermine com about phentermine amide phentermine best phentermine buy cheap phentermine online buy phentermine no prescription buy phentermine on line buy phentermine with mastercard buy phentermine without a prescription buy phentermine without prescription buying phentermine buying phentermine online cheap phentermine free shipping cheap phentermine no prescription cheap phentermine without prescription compare phentermine dangers of phentermine how does phentermine work hrt phentermine information on phentermine ingredients in phentermine is phentermine safe low cost phentermine lowest price phentermine natural phentermine non prescription phentermine ordering phentermine

E8

The Atlas of Lie Groups and Representations, a project to compute all unitary representations of real semisimple Lie groups, has successfully computed the Kazhdan-Lustig-Vogan polynomials of the split real form of the exceptional Lie group E8, a calculation. This result is so exciting that the American Institute of Mathematics
put out a press release comparing it to the Human Genome Project.

I can’t even imagine what an announcement like this looks like from the outside. I don’t know the significance of the result myself, though the classification of all unitary representations of Lie groups is obviously an important one. For a more detailed descriptions, see this post at the n-Category Cafe, and the ensuing discussion.

Pi Day?

I’ve seen multiple claims on the Internet that yesterday was Pi day. Was there a memo that I didn’t get? Who decided it was pi day?

I do remember quite clearly when I was in elementary school and the teacher announced that it was impossible to write pi as a fraction. I was shocked.

I was going to agitate for other deserving constants, such as Euler’s constant should get their own day, but honestly, I love every real number equally. They all deserve a day of their own.

Abramsky on Concurrency

David Corfield highlights two articles by Samson Abramsky: one on Temperley-Lieb algebras and the other on concurrency.

The concurrency article, What are the fundamental structures of concurrency? We still don’t know!, discusses the profusion of formalisms for representing concurrency. Abramsky passes on the following anecdote:

The mathematician André Weil apparently compared finding the right definitions in algebraic number theory — which was like carving adamantine rock—to making definitions in the theory of uniform spaces (which he founded), which was like sculpting with snow.

Math and Science Fiction

This post by Mark Chu-Carroll made me wonder something. Compared to people in the sciences or computers, are mathematicians disproportionately less likely to like science fiction? I’ve only known personally known a few that were big science fiction fans, while virtually every science blogger seems to be a big fan. Are science bloggers somehow a non-representative sample, or is this a genuine phenomenon?

Opportunity Cost Explained

The Annals of Improbable Research, perhaps the finest general-purpose scholarly journal today, has published a satire by Yoram Bauman of Greg Mankiw’s 10 principles of economics (from his introductory economics textbook). Most of it is hit-or-miss, but his summary of Principle #2 is a brilliant satire on the concept of opportunity cost.

Opportunity cost is easy enough to understand in simple descriptive situations, but I have never seen a precise mathematical definition of it that didn’t make it seem like a contentless idea.

3d incest 3d incest toon anime incest brother sister incest cartoon incest comic incest dad and daughter incest daddy daughter incest story daughter incest daughter incest incest erotske incest erotske price incest family incest family incest gallery father daughter incest father daughter incest story free incest free incest gallery free incest movie free incest pic free incest porn free incest sex story free incest story free incest video gay incest hentai incest illegal incest incest incest 3d incest art incest board incest cartoon incest chat incest clip incest comic incest erotica incest erotske price incest family incest forum incest gallery incest gay incest hentai incest house preview incest lesbian story incest mom incest mom with son incest movie incest pic incest picture incest porn incest porno incest pri c4 8de incest price incest rape incest sex incest sex story incest site incest story incest taboo incest toon incest video lesbian incest little incest little lolita eve incest girl mom son incest mother daughter incest mother son incest new incest family 56 mb preview pre teen incest sex preteen incest preteen incest story rape incest real incest real incest story russian incest sickest incest sin jebe majku incest price sister incest story of incest taboo incest teen hardcore incest picture teen incest teen incest sex toon incest topjapan lesbian incest twin incest underage incest pic young incest

Third Carnival of Mathematics

The third Carnival of Mathematics is out, at Michi’s blog.

airfox cialis best cialis price book buy cgi cialis guest buy cheap cialis buy cheap cialis online buy cialis buy cialis generic buy cialis generic online buy cialis now buy cialis online buy cialis online uk buy cialis online viagra buy cialis site buy generic cialis buying generic cialis canada cialis cheap cialis cheap cialis online cheap generic cialis cheapest cialis cheapest cialis generic cheapest cialis price cialis cialis 20mg cialis ambien wagering cialis attorney cialis buy cialis cheap cialis com cialis compare levitra viagra cialis comparison levitra viagra cialis discount cialis dosage cialis drug cialis drug impotence cialis eli lilly cialis fda cialis for sale cialis for woman cialis free sample cialis generic cialis generic tadalafil cialis generic viagra cialis icos cialis joke cialis lawsuits cialis lawyer cialis levitra cialis levitra sale viagra cialis levitra viagra vs cialis levitra vs cialis lilly cialis news cialis on line cialis online cialis online discount cialis online pharmacy cialis order cialis pill cialis prescription cialis price cialis purchase cialis review cialis sale cialis sale uk cialis sample cialis sample pack cialis side effects cialis soft cialis soft tab cialis tablet cialis tadalafil cialis taladafil cheap cialis uk cialis viagra cialis vs viagra discount cialis discount generic cialis free cialis generic cialis generic cialis online generic cialis price get viagra 2c cialis impotence drug cialis liquid cialis online cialis order cialis order cialis online order generic cialis prescription cialis purchase cialis purchase cialis online value pharmaceutical cialis viagra cialis viagra cialis levitra what is cialis